Sunday, 22 November 2026
economy money coins
Macro & EconomyThursday, November 19, 2026 at 07:02 AM UTC

Scottish government faces scrutiny over first 'kilt' bond issuance plans

Holyrood’s finance committee examined the risks and rewards of issuing Scotland’s inaugural bonds, dubbed 'kilts', to raise £1.5bn for long-term infrastructure projects.

By Salala Times Desk
Key points
  • The Scottish government aims to raise approximately £1.5bn through the new bond scheme by the end of the current parliamentary term in 2031.
  • Investors in the bonds, nicknamed 'kilts', receive regular interest payments and principal repayment, with the funds designated for capital projects like hospitals and roads.
  • The Scottish government holds an identical credit rating to the UK, based on prudent fiscal management, though ministers were warned this could shift if independence moves forward.
  • The Scottish government’s borrowing limit for capital spending is capped at £3bn, adjusted for inflation, with about £491m available for the current financial year.

The primary objective is to raise approximately £1.5bn by 2031, with the capital earmarked for long-term infrastructure projects such as hospital construction and road maintenance.

The scheme has been colloquially named "kilts," a direct reference to UK government bonds known as "gilts." While the government intends to launch the bonds within the current financial year, subject to market conditions, the timing has drawn criticism. Concerns have been raised about proceeding with the issuance amidst global market volatility driven by conflicts in Ukraine and the Middle East. However, David McMillan, a professor of finance and accounting at the University of Stirling, argued before MSPs that waiting for ideal market conditions is impractical.

Borrowing limits and budget context

The proposed bond issuance represents a small fraction of the Scottish government’s total budget, which stands at nearly £70bn. The majority of this budget, roughly four-fifths, is allocated to resource spending, covering day-to-day operational costs such as NHS funding, benefits payments, and public sector salaries. The government is legally restricted from borrowing for these resource costs, except to correct forecasting errors.

In contrast, the government is permitted to borrow for capital spending, which funds physical assets like buildings, bridges, and infrastructure. Under current rules, the borrowing cap is set at £450m annually at 2023-24 levels, with a total cumulative limit of £3bn. This limit is uprated with inflation, allowing for approximately £491m in borrowing for the current financial year.

Cost comparisons and credit ratings

Economists have highlighted that the new bond scheme may be more expensive than existing borrowing routes available through the UK government’s National Loans Fund. There is an estimated administrative cost of £2m per bond issued. The Scottish government has not released detailed costings, citing market sensitivities, but maintains that the scheme offers value for money compared to the UK borrowing scheme.

In November of last year, the government announced it had secured a credit rating identical to that of the UK. This rating was attributed to prudent fiscal management and the country’s economic stability. However, ministers were cautioned that this rating could change if Scotland moves toward independence.

Transparency and political concerns

The proposal originated from initial work commissioned by former First Minister Humza Yousaf in 2023, following recommendations from the Scottish government’s Investor Panel. The panel suggested that issuing bonds would help raise Scotland’s profile and attract investment. Ministers argue that the scheme provides flexibility for public finances and debt management, while also serving as a strategic tool for marketing the country to investors.

Conservative MSP Liam Kerr expressed concerns that the bonds could be more costly than borrowing through the National Loans Fund and criticized the lack of transparency in the programme. McMillan agreed with the principles of the plan but warned that limiting the bonds to a five-year horizon could damage credibility with investors.

Key elements of the proposed bond scheme include:

  • The target to raise £1.5bn by 2031 for long-term capital projects such as hospitals and roads.
  • An estimated interest rate premium of 0.3 percentage points above UK gilt rates.
  • An administrative cost of £2m for each bond issued.
  • A total borrowing cap for capital spending of £3bn, adjusted for inflation.
  • An identical credit rating to the UK government, based on current fiscal management.
Sources
Based on reporting by BBC News.

More in Macro & Economy

View all →